[Skip Header] Friend Requests Messages Notifications HomeProfile Account(more) [End of Header]

About this Author

Kczar alakdan helps mentoring programs for children.

Circumcision

by Kczar alakdan on April 21, 2013

'Jews survived thanks to brit milah, Niddah'

Anthropologist Melvin Konner views male circumcision, family purity as two mitzvot which can explain Jewish people's survival to this day. And yes, it has to do with Darwin's theory

Tzofia Hirschfeld

The history of the world is filled with empires that controlled the world, but the Jewish people were never one of those. Jews have always been a minority, and for long periods of time – a persecuted minority.

Seemingly, in light of the wars, exiles and destruction, the Jewish people should have disappeared by now – but they haven't. How did Jews survive?

Anthropologist Melvin Konner of Emory University, Atlanta, attributes the Jewish people's survival to their devotion to some of the mitzvot of the Torah, which he says were specifically suited to guarantee the continued existence of the children of Abraham.

 According to Prof. Konner, circumcision and practicing family purity (Niddah) are mitzvot which allowed and encouraged the birth of a greater number of offspring, contributing to the people's continued existence.

He adds that the model of prolific mothers matches Darwin's Natural Selection theory, according to which many offspring improve the chances of survival. In other words, "be fruitful and multiply" is a winning formula.

   Relevant mitzvotKonner presented his theory last week at the conference on "Judaism in Evolutionary Perspective" at the Schechter Institute of Jewish Studies in Jerusalem.

"The existence of the Jewish people throughout history, in light of the exiles and persecution, is a real challenge," says Konner. "Religious people see this as divine intervention.

"There is no doubt that their commitment to religious texts helped, but if we look

12 Comments

good post keep it up such nice post

18 months ago

great post on circumcision

18 months ago

Thank you. sorry for the delay of response. I don't know what happened why it took this long for me to see you were here...

4 months ago

Good post ..
I like it .. keep it up.
Thanks for sharing

18 months ago

Thank you ..yah, I hope i can dig some more good articles to share or to make my own...

18 months ago

great information to share with

16 months ago

Well, I hope you enjoyed, though it was already a year ago...

4 months ago

interesting post.

16 months ago

Thank you Chochay

4 months ago

Good article...

15 months ago

Thank you for that

4 months ago